WHAT IS THE HARM IF THIS ADVICE OF THE LORD IS NOT FOLLOWED?
ye twetad abhyasooyanto naanutishthanti me matam
sarvajnaanavimoodham staan viddhi nashtaan achetasah // 3.32 //
But those who find fault with my teaching and do not practice it, deluded in all knowledge and devoid of discrimination, know them to be doomed to destruction.
Sri Krishna warns here that those who are obstinate in finding fault with His teachings without practicing them are doomed for destruction. Such people will be more and more deluded and will lose their discrimination.
Karma Yoga is a way of life and one has to live it if one wants to receive His grace. The path of work is a process of elimination of desires in us. When egoism and egocentric desires are eliminated the work done through such pure mind is a divine action which will have enduring achievements. To the extent an individual does not practice this efficient way of work he loses his discriminative capacity and ultimately will meet his destruction.
ACTION IS DRIVEN BY ONE’S OWN NATURE
sadrisham cheshtate swasyaah prakriter jnaanavaan api
prakritim yaanti bhootani nigrahah kim karishyati // 3.33 //
Even a wise man acts in accordance with his own nature; beings will follow nature; what can restraint do?
The question as to why some people do not follow the teachings of The Lord and instead act on their own is answered in this verse; the reason is that their lower nature proves too strong for them. Every one is conditioned by his thoughts which in turn are influenced by his nature (tendency) or prakriti. Even an honest person finds it difficult to practice the technique in life shown by The Lord because of his own mental conditioning overwhelmed by his incapacity to pursue the path of action.
Prakriti is the mental equipment with which one is born as the result of the past acts performed in a previous life. This nature is the mainspring of the man’s action. This must run its course; there is no escape from this and even God cannot prevent its operation (Shankara). Even He ordains that past deeds produce their natural effects.
Restraint or forcible repression of senses for renouncing activities cannot be of much avail since actions flow inevitably from the workings of Prakriti and the Self is only an important witness. This indicates the omnipotence of the nature over the Self which makes us to act according to our nature, the law of our being. However, this is not a statement of despair to the effect that there is no scope for personal exertion to reach the highest goal and that the teachings of Sri Krishna are all purposeless. On the other hand it is a call to find out our true being and give expression to it as explained in the next verse.
ROLE FOR PERSONAL EXERTION
indriyasye'ndriyasyaarthe raagadweshau vyavasthitau
tayor na vasham aagacchet tau hyasya paripanthinau // 3.34 //
The love and hatred that the senses feel for their objects are inevitable. But let none come under their sway; for, they are his enemies.
Attachment and aversion of the sense organs to sense objects are natural to every one. Although the sense objects as such are not capable of attraction or repulsion it is the mind which produces such agitations because of its being conditioned by vasanas. Thus mind develops attachment for the agreeable objects and aversion for disagreeable ones. Sri Krishna does not advise running away from the sense objects but emphatically says `Let none come under its sway' meaning that one should be a master of the senses and not their victim.
If we do not interfere attachments and aversions will determine our acts. So long as we act in certain ways because we like them and abstain from some others because we dislike them we will be bound by our actions.
But if we overcome these impulses from our egocentric ideas and act from a sense of duty, we cannot be the victims of the play of Prakriti. Thus in the process of controlling the mind - stopping it from running after the objects of attachment and aversion - lies the personal exertion for the seeker. That is his Purushartha.
Linking this advice to the previous verse it can be understood that it is not possible for anybody to renounce all his activities forcibly. But man can by changing the aim of his life, turn the course of life from one direction to the other. In other words, avoiding likes and dislikes he can convert his actions as aids to God-realization.
DANGER IN PERCEIVING OTHER’S DUTIES AS BETTER THAN ONE’S OWN
shreyaan swadharmo vigunah paradharmaat swanushthitaat
swadharme nidhanam shreyah paradharmo bhayaavahah // 3.35 //
Better is one's own duty, though imperfectly performed, than the duty of another well performed. Better is death in the doing of one's own duty; the duty of another is fraught with peril.
Although the word Dharma is meant here as duty, in a special sense it is one's own basic nature or vasana. Swadharma is the type of vasanas one finds in his mind. To act according to one's taste, inborn and natural, is the only method to live in peace and joy. To act against one's vasanas is to act in terms of Paradharma which is fraught with danger.
Here the Swadharma of Arjuna is that of a prince and not that of Brahmana. He wanted to take up the latter abandoning the former. In this verse Sri Krishna reminds him that to act according to his own vasanas or Dharma, even though imperfect, is the right path for his development. It is dangerous to suppress one's own personality expression and imitate the activities of others, however divinely they may be. There is more happiness in doing one's own work even without excellence than in doing another's duty well. We must play our part, manfully, be it great or small.
The implication is that Arjuna's thought of desisting from fight and going in for the calm and peaceful life of a Brahmana is prompted by man's natural desire to shun what is disagreeable and adopt what is momentarily agreeable to the senses. He should on no account yield to such weakness. It is indeed much better for a person to die while discharging his own duty, though it may not have any merit, than doing the duty of another, though it may be performed in a perfect manner, because the duty of another has many pitfalls.