7—9) "As the various particular kinds of notes of a drum, when it is beaten,
cannot be grasped by themselves, but are grasped only when the general note of
the drum or the general sound produced by different kinds of strokes is grasped;
"And as the various particular notes of a conch, when it is blown, cannot be
grasped by themselves, but are grasped only when the general note of the conch
or the general sound produced by different kinds of blowing is grasped; "And as
the various particular notes of a vina, when it is played, cannot be grasped by
themselves, but are grasped Only when the general note of the vina or the
general sound produced by different kinds of playing is grasped; Similarly, no
particular objects are perceived in the waking and dream states apart from Pure
Intelligence.
By these three illustrations, sage Yajnavalkya tells us that the effect cannot
be known unless the cause is known, because the effect is a manifestation of the
cause in some proportion. We cannot understand the nature of any object in this
world unless we know wherefrom it has come. Unless the cause behind the form
that is visible is perceived, the form cannot be really known or understood.
If we are intent upon knowing the nature of any object, we must know its
relation to something else. And that something else is connected to another
thing, and so on and so on, until we will be surprised to realize that
everything is connected to everything else in such a way that nothing can be
known unless everything is known. So, it is not possible to have complete
knowledge of any finite object unless the Infinite itself is known.
To understand this, the great Master Yajnavalkya gives us three illustrations.
Just as the sound that is made by a percussion instrument cannot be properly
identified if the instrument itself is far away and not visible to the eyes, but
whose sound is heard by us from a distance, unless we catch the source thereof;
just as we cannot identify the rhythm produced by the blowing of a conch unless
we have the capacity to grasp the totality of the sound by actually perceiving
the conch that is being blown at any particular time; just as we cannot
understand the symphony produced by a Veena or a stringed instrument, for
instance, merely by hearing one note unless we are able to connect all the notes
in a harmonious symphony, so is the case with all these things in this world.
The particular notes or tunes from a musical instrument are modifications of the
general note emanating from it; they cannot be perceived because they have no
existence apart from the general note.
All things in the universe are each like one note in the symphony. How can we
know the beauty of the music by merely hearing one note? That note is connected
to many other notes. And when every note is harmoniously related to all other
notes to which it is related, and all the notes are grasped at one stroke in one
single harmonious symphony, that becomes music; it is melodious. But if only a
twang is heard or one tick is heard, it makes no sense; it is not music.
So is the case with any object in this world. It is one twang, one tick, one
sound which is really connected to a vast arena of a symphony that is
universally expansive. Unless that total expanse or continuity is grasped by the
mind at one stroke, which means that unless the infinite Being behind the finite
objects is grasped by the consciousness, no finite object can be known fully,
nothing can be understood perfectly. Therefore, nothing can give us
satisfaction. During the continuance of the universe, all diverse entities are
unified in Brahman or Pure Intelligence, because the varieties or diversities
are not different from It. Thus there is no hope of immortality through any
possession in this world, is the conclusion of Sage Yajnavalkya.
What Yajnavalkya says is that the nature of effects cannot be known unless their
cause is known. It is futile on our part to investigate into the nature of any
finite object without correlating its form and context with the causes which
gave rise to its present form.
But, the incapacity of the senses to perceive the causes behind the visible
forms creates a false impression in the mind that the causes are completely
isolated from the existence of the effect. This is why we make independent
notional judgments about things, distancing them from the conditions from which
they are evolved, which are ultimately cosmic conditions. The point made out in
the Upanishad, in this passage, is that without the knowledge of the Absolute,
not even the smallest of things can be understood and that nothing exists apart
from Brahman, Pure Intelligence.
10) "As from a fire kindled with wet fuel various kinds of smoke issue forth,
even so, my dear, the Rig Veda, the Yajur Veda, the Sama Veda, the
Atharvangirasa, history (itihasa), mythology (purana), the arts (vidya), the
Upanishads, verses (slokas), aphorisms (sutras), elucidations (anuvyakhyanas)
and explanations (vyakhyanas) are like the breath of this infinite Reality. From
this Supreme Self are all these, indeed, breathed forth.
Now, this passage tells us that everything proceeds from that Pure Intelligence,
the Absolute. How does it come?
We cannot understand how anything can come from the Absolute. We can only give
some illustrations, and the Upanishad employs here the comparison of smoke
arising from fire. Just as when wet fuel is burnt smoke may arise from
its burning process, everything may be said to proceed in this manner, as it
were, from the Supreme Being - a continuous emanation. As before the separation
of the sparks, embers, and flames, all these are nothing but fire and therefore
there is but one substance, fire, so too, this universe before it differentiated
itself into names and forms, is nothing but Pure Intelligence.
Evam va are asya mahato bhutasya nihsvasitam: From the breathing, as it
were, of this eternal, infinite Reality, all the knowledge of this world has
come. Just as when you breathe out there is a breath coming from your nostrils,
the Absolute breathes, as it were, this wisdom of all His creation. And, all
this wisdom of the world put together cannot be equated with a fraction of It.
The wisdom of the Vedas and everything that is capable of being connected with
Vedic knowledge, such as the Itihasas, Puranas, Vidya, all arts and all branches
of learning, secret teachings, verses and poetic compositions, aphorisms,
commentaries, anything that can be called knowledge, in whatever way, whatever
manner, whatever form, everything has come out from Brahman as a man’s breath
comes out without any effort.
11) "As the ocean is the one goal of all waters (i.e. the place where they
merge), so the skin is the one goal of all kinds of touch, the nostrils are the
one goal of all smells, the tongue is the one goal of all tastes, the ear is the
one goal of all sounds, the mind is the one goal of all deliberations, the
intellect is the one goal of all forms of knowledge, the hands are the one goal
of all actions, the organ of generation is the one goal of all kinds of
enjoyment, the excretory organ is the one goal of all excretions, the feet are
the one goal of all kinds of walking, the organ of speech is the one goal of all
the Vedas.
The ocean is the repository of all waters on the earth. The touch-sense
and everything that we regard as meaningful from the point of view of
tangibility is located in the skin. Every kind of taste can be located
ultimately in the structural pattern of the tongue, or the palate. Every
smell, every odor, every type of fragrance is located in the structure of
the nostrils. Every color, every form, everything that is visible,
is located in the structure of the eyes. Every sound, whatever it is, is
located in the structure of the ears. Every thought, every
feeling, anything that is cogitated is ultimately located in the mind.
Every feeling, every kind of intimation, connected with the knowledge of things,
is in the heart of a person. Every action, the capacity to grasp things, is
located in the energy of the hands of a person.
Other organs also are mentioned in this manner, making out that all activities
of the senses are capable of being traced back to the structure of the senses,
so that if we know the nature of the sense-organs concerned in any particular
action, whether it is the action of knowledge or merely of locomotion, enjoyment
etc., we can know everything connected with that particular organ. Likewise, we
can know all things if we can locate their origin, from where they proceed.
All these different examples signify the idea of one common goal, one common
centre where all merge. Similarly the whole universe is ultimately centered in
this one Reality which is the source of all.
12) "As a lump of salt dropped into water becomes dissolved in water and
cannot be taken out again, but wherever we taste the water it tastes salt, even
so, my dear, this great, endless, infinite Reality is Pure Intelligence alone.
This self comes out as a separate entity from these elements and with their
destruction this separate existence also is destroyed. After attaining oneness
it has no more consciousness. This is what I say, my dear." So said Yajnavalkya.
Another illustration is given here to make out the nature of the Supreme Being
from whom all knowledge proceeds. If we dissolve a little piece of salt in
water, what happens? The salt becomes one with the water. We may take any part
of that water, it will taste salty, and we cannot find out where the salt is. It
has become one with the water; it is everywhere in the water.
Just as any part of that water in which salt is dissolved will taste of salt
only, because of the pervasive character of the salt that has got dissolved into
the water, so is the Infinite Being. How? It is a mass of knowledge; it is a
treasure house of wisdom; it is a substantiality of what we regard as the
highest Consciousness; that is this ultimate Reality. Wherever we touch, it is
that which is touched, and wherever we taste we are tasting that only, and
anything that is seen anywhere is naturally that only. Whatever be the
corresponding object of a particular sense-organ, it is the form of That which
is seen. And the mind thinks nothing but That, not knowing it is so doing.
This consciousness which is solid Reality ultimately, the substantiality of the
whole universe, appears to localize itself in the body of individuals by
entering into the process of permutation and combination of the elements like
earth, water, fire, air, ether, etc. A particular combination in some percentage
of these five elements becomes a body, an embodiment. When consciousness enters
this particular formation of the elements, it is what we call the individual,
the Jiva, or a particular finite body. It arises in this form and dissolves
itself in this form, as it were, as long as it is connected to this formation of
the elements.
The birth of the individual and the death of the individual are described here,
as being the consequence of the association and dissolution of consciousness
within the formation of the five elements in a certain proportion. It is the
five elements which combine in certain ways and conditions that are responsible
for the objects of sense, as we call them.
Animate or inanimate, whatever may be - all the objects, all the bodies are
really the elements in some shape, color and tangibility. They appear to have a
value, a worth, and meaning, because of the entry of consciousness into them.
And when the formations change, when there is a different type of formation of
the elements that is called the death of the individual.
It is not a death really; it is a transformation, a reformation of the
particular form into which these elements have been cast by the need of that
unit of consciousness which is called the Jiva. When this consciousness gets
entangled in the forms of the elements, it is called birth. When it is freed
from them, it is called death. When it is freed from the elements, it will not
be conscious of any particular thing.
Yajnavalkya tells Maitreyi that when there is total isolation of consciousness
from all its associations in the form of these permutations and combinations of
elements called the body, there would be no particular consciousness. There
would be no feeling, hearing, touching, smelling, - nothing particular
whatsoever, no consciousness at all. So says Yajnavalkya, "after dissolution,
there is no awareness". This is what is meant by this pithy statement - na
pretya samjnasti. "Maitreyi; this I tell you. Try to understand it."