Ayurveda
as an independent medical school has served the social needs of Indian
subcontinent since time immemorial, and even to countries around India. Till
the late 20th century, it survived in the country as a traditional
school of learning unlike the other streams of learning. There were different
educational institutions across the country that were teaching Ayurveda in
different modes. Until the mid 20th century, Ayurveda was taught in
Vedic institutions in the form of Upaveda of Atharva Veda, in many parts of the nation. It was also taught in the form of “Gurukul” system. A better example of this are the generations of traditional Ashtavaidya
families of Kerala teaching the respective branches of Ayurveda.
The post independence period of India has seen major advancement and reforms in all sectors of society such as healthcare, education, medical education, agriculture, irrigation, and economics. However, the major challenge in front of the government was poor health index and high mortality rate. As a result, provision of primary and social health care has remained a priority area in the planning process. Government of India gave a special attention for the development of indigenous medical sciences. As a result, various committees were formed to initiate the reforms in Ayurveda. Although there were quite good initiatives and measures taken to improve Ayurveda education in India, still it was endeavouring to establish as a comprehensive system of learning that could be applied in its right sense for the benefit of the mankind. On the other side, Allopathic system grew rapidly in par with the western world due to the commonality of learning and applicability. The successive governments also gave much priority to Allopathic systems than Ayurveda. However, the advent of 21st
century has provided a new horizon of opportunities to the traditional medical
sciences. The WHO has also in contemplated to provide an identity to the
traditional medical sciences.
In India, providing healthcare for 1.2 billion population is a tedious task. India has been spending just about 1.2% of its gross domestic product (GDP) on the health sector, perhaps the lowest in the world. In the 12th five year plan (2012–2017), the government has proposed a significant increase in the expenditure on health care. For the 1st time in the history of
the Republic of India, a basic framework of Universal Health Coverage has been
proposed. National Rural Health Mission (NRHM, 2005), was launched to
strengthen the rural public health system. The mission sought to provide
effective healthcare to the rural population throughout the country. Through
NRHM, Government of India has initiated revolutionary steps in bringing the
AYUSH systems (Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy) to
the larger population through Primary Health Centre (PHC), Community Health
Centre (CHC) and District Hospitals level in par with Allopathic systems.
The 21st century has opened a new gateway for the traditional medical systems. To serve the nation better through Ayurveda is indeed a very important task. To achieve this, producing well qualified, knowledgeable Ayurveda doctors who can deliver the best healthcare through Ayurveda is the challenge ahead of Ayurveda fraternity. There is a constant debate at all levels regarding the delivery of standard Ayurveda education to its aspirers. There is always a dilemma that exists among the policy makers of Ayurveda education, whether to follow Allopathic education standards in Ayurveda or to develop an altogether novel approach for Ayurvedic education. The introduction of 5½ year course existing now has partially succeeded in giving Ayurvedic education, and now yearly pattern has been introduced. However, still there is a strong opinion existing that, Ayurveda cannot be learned completely in the span of 5 years along with modern subjects in the syllabus. The debate still persists in the present scenario.
Unlike
Allopathic education Ayurveda needs to be learned with a holistic approach
since the core approach of understanding health and disease is entirely
different from modern medical science. When we speak about reforms in the
Ayurveda education system, it is not mere changing of the duration or short
listing the subjects and introducing modern medical subjects, rather it should
include the core Ayurveda philosophy intact with essential technical
adaptations for global need. Since there is a strong need for an Ayurveda
medical system to prove its relevance as a complete scientific system in the
current world, it needs to adopt recent scientific advancements in Ayurveda
education for that.
What Are the Challenges Ahead of Ayurvedic Education?
The major challenge ahead of Ayurvedic education is to produce competent Ayureda medical practitioners; perhaps the existing system has not been completely successful in producing confidence among Ayurveda graduates for practicing pure Ayurveda. There may be several reasons attributing towards this, including student's inability to understand principles of Ayurveda practice, improper infra-structure in Ayurveda institutions, unskilled teachers, etc.
One of the important aspect which is unable to bind the essence of Ayurveda
with students is the lack of Sanskrit knowledge, although the Sanskrit subject
taught in the 1st year syllabus has not served the purpose
effectively. Hence, Sanskrit subject should also be taught from the perspective
of Ayurveda. Another best way out for this problem is to provide translated
versions of all Ayurveda classics in regional languages as additional study
materials may help to understand the principle and philosophy of the subjects
better.
Another important challenge is the lack of adequate practical exposure in
clinical practice. Most of the Ayurveda institutions lack the proper
infrastructure and sufficient patient flow required to develop clinical
orientation in the students undergo strict surveillance for the provision of
the best facilities to institutions.
The essential reforms required in Ayurveda education can be listed as follows:
- There should not be repeated
alterations of academic durations of Ayurveda curriculum since it disturbs
the adaptability and nature among Ayurveda teachers, and if the change is
needed it should be executed with appropriate measures taken in advance,
like providing a standard teaching methodology training to teachers
- Periodical review of
subjects is required to facilitate inclusion of recent scientific
advancements and not merely excluding existing subjects
- There should be freedom in
the medium of instruction for a better understanding of Ayurveda since
most of the students find it difficult to understand Sanskrit and writing
it in English increasing their difficulty
- The governing council should
not increase the number of educational institutions, but to give priority
for quality institutions with running hospitals
- The current view of
introducing semester system should be withdrawn, it serves no purpose
either for students or teachers and perhaps it triggers many confusions
and technical difficulties
- The yearly or earlier
phase-wise system should be retained, but institutional assessments should
be valued so that student can revive his understanding
- The availability of herbal
garden in the educational institutions can be instrumental in acquainting
the students about the various medicinal plants
- The examination reforms are
to be introduced, the present examination system is focused on mere
subject wise notes and classical references, perhaps it has no scope for
evaluation of individual understanding of the subject
- The examination pattern should be more of assessing the student's ability in the understanding of the subject in the purview of Ayurveda principles and should be prioritized
- The questions appearing in
examination should be in the nature of extracting reasoning and analytical
skills of students for existing clinical problem
- There should be very
intensive and highly practical oriented rotatory compulsory internships to
be designed, and there should be minimal eligibility practical tests after
each departmental posting
- The 1 year period of
internship can be extended if the student is found inefficient in
practicing Ayurveda
- Developing an interest in
the subject is essential to understand it thoroughly. Teachers are the
guiding forces in the lives of students. Presence of skilled teachers can
enhance the interest about the concerned subject.
These are the few things which I feel are required in to bring in Ayurveda education with the view of producing competent Ayurveda practitioners through well-organized student–teacher friendly Ayurveda education curriculum.
To read
article in PDF format.
Article
availableonline/offlineon: AYU, Vol. 36, Issue-3, Jan-Sept 2015, Page
no.231-232, for more details please visit: www.ayujournal.org
About Author:
Prof. Mahesh Vyas, Executive
Editor - AYU, IPGT and RA, Gujarat Ayurved University, Jamnagar - 361008,
Gujarat, India
No part of this article may be reproduced in full or part without written permission of the Ayu Journal who can be contacted at ayujournal@yahoo.com