- This
article simply tells what are U.S. Characteristics and sources of American Power?
Why is U.S. power falling? How can India deal with the U.S.?
I
last wrote How India can
understand that Friendship with China is a DREAM . A reader suggested I write a similar article for India and USA. Complex! This piece is more relevant after the Xi, Trump and Putin meeting in Shenzen, China in November 26.
Why does U.S.
often see itself not just as a country among many, but as a leader?
Dr Subhasis wrote, “American Exceptionalism is the belief that the United States is a special and unique country. People who believe in this idea think that America has a special role to play in the world. They believe America is different from other countries because of its history, its political system, and its values like freedom, democracy, and human rights.”
Further, “After World War II, the US
emerged as a global leader, promoting democracy and rebuilding economies.
During the Cold War, it positioned itself as a model of freedom and prosperity.
At its peak, the US consistently ranked at the top of global indices,
reinforcing its US soft power ranking as one of the strongest in the world.” Source
This piece is about the U.S. government for whom national interest not friends are permanent. Areas covered below are broadly Military, Technology, Money, Soft Power, U.S. Society and Politics.
At the outset, state that I love visiting the U.S. and admire it for a variety of reasons including opportunities it provides.
What are U.S. Characteristics and the source of American
Strength?
1.
U.S.A. is a Christian country. Anglo-Saxon is the right word. The President
takes oath, with one hand on the Bible.
2.
The Arms industry lobbies are very powerful.
They are huge, in terms of exports (e.g. missiles, aircraft) and domestic
market (e.g. guns). Ukraine is after the U.S. for its Patriot air defence
system to counter Russian ballistic missiles.
3.
Oil Majors like Exxon and Chevron play an important
role in government policy, even if not directly. When U.S. interests may be
hurt, something happens.
4.
The Church is powerful in the U.S. The U.S.
Church has been for years, amongst the largest donors to Indian NGOs. Why FCRA 2 is
being opposed
5.
Technology companies like Microsoft, Google,
Nvidia rule parts of the world. Recent Microsoft outage created problems
worldwide excluding mainland China.
6.
U.S. has large Banks like JP Morgan
Chase, Bank of America, Citibank, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley.
7.
U.S. Dollar is the world’s reserve currency. “A reserve currency is a safe, widely accepted money type that governments and central banks hold in large amounts.” Source
8. “SWIFT (Society for
Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication) is a secure global messaging network that connects over 11,500 financial institutions in more than 200 countries and territories” is headquarted in Belgium. U.S. Dollar control and sanctions are what gives the U.S. real power over it.
“When
non-cooperative countries or entities violate international rules, cutting them off from SWIFT effectively isolates them from the global economy, blocking trade, freezing foreign currency assets, and crippling their financial systems.” Russia and Iran are latest victims of
SWIFT.
9.
U.S. exports its Soft Power through Hollywood,
Digital platforms, lifestyle, educational leadership and brands like
McDonalds/Starbucks Coffee.
10.
U.S. believes it has the right to comment on human rights, conditions of
minorities, secularism in virtually every country outside the Anglo-Saxon world
but the reverse is not acceptable. It does not matter it does not practice
that.
A
U.S. President (Obama) can come to New Delhi and speak about Rights of
Minorities in India
but an Indian PM will never do that in Washington.
Former President
Obama taking oath with hand on the Bible. Credits MINT
12. U.S. is home to some of world’s leading educational
schools like Harvard, MIT and Stanford. Their schools attract students
from across the world and contribute to the U.S. economy, in terms of spending
and talent.
Tata Centre, Harvard. 2015.
13.
U.S. houses the United Nations (NY), World
Bank and IMF in Washington.
14.
U.S. encourages meritocracy, innovation and risk taking.
15. U.S. has some of the world’s largest pharma
companies. A search for the top five pharma
companies by innovation shows three U.S. cos namely El Lilly, Pfizer, E
Merck. The emphasis on research is often overlooked.
As
India discovered during Covid19 vaccine, profit maximization is the goal. It
did not work for India who developed an
Indian one.
U.S.
medicines are expensive. Generics, cheaper, are exported by Indian
companies in large quantities to the U.S.
Indian American professionals are grateful for opportunities that the U.S. has provided them and many are known like Indra Nooyi of Pepsico. However, resident Indians should not expect
them to publicly lobby for India. Work silently behind closed doors. NRI’s can contribute in other ways.
The U.S. welcomed many Indian Gurus like Swami Vivekananda, Paramhanda Yogananda, Swami Prabhupada (founder ISKCON) etc some of whom got known in India more after returning from the U.S.
Vivekananda House in South Pasadena. In 1900 Swami Vivekananda House stayed here for 6 weeks.
Sanatana Dharma Mandir, Los Angeles provides free medical check up for select citizens.2019.
Cycle Rickshaw, Washington. 2015.
Shoe Polishing. Washington Bus Terminus. 2015.
Why U.S. is a losing Superpower? (not in order of priority)
The
U.S. was respected for democracy, political system, economic progress etc.
1. However, the 2021 violence in Capitol Hill in the aftermath of the Presidential Election damaged U.S. reputation. “A bipartisan Senate report found that at least seven people had lost their lives in connection with the Jan. 6 attack.” Source New York
Times Jan 3, 2022
The aftermath of riots at the Capitol Hill building.
2. Violence in Washington pales in comparison to what happened in Seattle, Portland etc during the Black Lives
Matter-Antifa violence in 2020 that was caused by the killing of George Floyd. How a Year of
protests changed Seattle And Atleast 20
Americans were killed during protests and political unrests in 2020
The U.S. not
socially cohesive as it seemed to be. Further, deep political division exists.
3. In 2021, 48,830 died from gun related injuries in the U.S. (April 26, 2023 report of Pew Research) What sort
of democracy is this?
4. The last Roman Catholic President, before Joe Biden, was John F Kennedy, who was killed in
1963. Source Pew Research Since
then, was the democratic setup in U.S. not concerned about sentiments of the RC
minority?
Earlier such double standards were unsaid but no longer.
5. Recurrence of financial scandals. Lehman Brothers 2008, U.S.
Energy Trading company Enron 2001 The world looks up to America/Europe as the epitome of
management and corporate governance. Silicon Valley Bank Collapse-Should an Indic Work Model
replace the Protestant one
Author
and columnist Devina Mehra wrote in the MINT that Nvidia CEO J Huang had sixty direct reports, unheard of even in India’s much maligned family businesses. How is it that Corporate governance and Management Gurus did not flag this shortcoming in Nvidia’s corporate structure and governance.
6. Increasing U.S. debt, already over 100% of GDP is a cause for global concern. How will the U.S. reduce its debt is an often asked question?
Shiva as
Sadashiva or Mahesha late 10th century Chola period. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. 2015.
7. Senior Journalist R Jagganathan
wrote, “My top candidate for rogue state is Uncle Sam, the world’s primary superpower. Any country that can kidnap an elected President in another country (Venezuela), threaten allies in Europe over Greenland and get its way, create chaos in Libya and Syria, decapitate the heads of another sovereign state (Iran), bomb
a capital city in Europe (Belgrade) for 78 days (to force it to let a province secede), goad Russia into a war over Ukraine (under Joe Biden) by endlessly expanding NATO.”
8. Did you know that the U.S. has not built a major Oil Refinery in 50 years? Problem is they were busy fighting wars in Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan etc.
9. U.S. speaks against terrorism whilst supporting a country i.e. Pakistan that has made export of terrorism an instrument of state policy. It supported a country that gave shelter to Osama Laden.
9/11/ Memorial, New York. 2015.
10. “Frequent shifts in tariff policy, multilateral commitments, and security priorities under the Trump administration have prompted some traditional allies to hedge their bets and look for alternative partners. It weaponised sanctions and SWIFT. Fissures with Europe complicated matters.
11. In electronics, automobiles, rare earths, infrastructure building etc China and Japan are ahead. It is in Artificial Intelligence that a battle is being fought between China and the U.S.
12. In many countries esp. South America, China has undercut the U.S. and got strategic control of global resources. However, the U.S. lacks the financial and economic muscle of earlier or was pre-occupied with wars.
Ganesha. Museum of
Fine Arts, Boston. 2015.
13. The U.S. Iran War has exposed the U.S. in many ways.
One, limitations of
bombing Iran because it has not led to victory in 9 months. Two, limited capacity of U.S. Industrial
Defence Base-seems to be running short of missiles etc. Three, rise of petroleum prices in the U.S. and diesel shortage
forcing imports from Russia to cool prices. Four,
failure of U.S. Intelligence to know nature and quantity of missiles/drones. Five, inability to take action against
China for tacitly supporting Iran because the U.S. is just so dependant on
China for so many things- rare earths, electronics, garments etc. China helps
reduce the U.S. inflation rate.
Six, inability to
protect its Gulf Allies from Iranian attacks. Once faith in the U.S. abilities
are broken, it could take decades for it to be rebuilt. Seven, underestimating asymmetric threats like from low-cost
drones. Eight, the badly timed Iran
War has brought Russia and China much closer and united them with adversaries like
North Korea, Iran.
Nine, increase in cost of crude and
related shipping/insurance costs plus supply disruptions made the U.S.
unpopular with people worldwide. Ten,
Iran has exposed the limitations of U.S. Naval Power. Eleven, Over-confidence and underestimating the enemies.
“The central paradox is that military power can start and sustain a conflict without controlling its economic consequences, or deciding who finally pays for them. In an increasingly interconnected world, the capacity to wage war and the capacity to absorb its costs have become dangerously separated.” Source
The U.S. may still win the Iran War but at what cost!
The U.S. is learning that it is easy to start a war but difficult to end it – the importance of a four day Operation Sindoor dawns.
14. Retaliatory Tariffs of 2025 - As if the
Ukraine and Iran Wars were not enough, the U.S. opened another front in Tariffs
to curb trade deficit. Were U.S. policy makers asleep when China was flooding
the U.S. market with cheap goods?
It is the U.S.
prerogative to impose tariffs but timing matters.
Just
as I fully support the U.S. decision to tighten the screws on illegal
immigrants but there is a way to do it.
15. Start of the U.S. downfall began probably, when it outsourced
manufacturing to China. U.S. Corporates made profits but lost what could
decades to recover. Manufacturing is an ecosystem, not merely a collection of factories.
When America outsourced production, it also weakened supplier networks, tooling
capabilities, engineering skills and industrial communities.
Today key drivers of the U.S. economy are export of Arms, Oil, Agricultural products, domestic consumption and retaining dollar as the world’s trading currency. Rulers who work against American interest may not survive. Ask Saddam Hussain!
16. America's real crisis is not simply declining global dominance. It is the weakening of its ability to continuously renew the industrial and physical infrastructure that made its dominance possible. Infrastructure is the foundation of civilisation. Roads, bridges, railways, ports, power grids, factories and water systems outlast governments, ideologies and technological revolutions.
17. The increasing Islamization in the U.S. might add to social tensions as it is doing in Europe.
Still, I believe that the U.S. can reinvent itself and provide balanced global leadership.
Shenzhen meeting says a lot. Table Round represents the world. In centre is China with Russia and USA on either side. Thanks BBC for this lovely pic.
So how should India approach the U.S.?
There
is a lot that unites us. India and the U.S. must agree to disagree. Even
husband wife do not agree on everything, two countries is different.
Help the Diaspora strengthen bonds with India. Since Reservations in India is bound to remain, students shall continue to go to the U.S. to study. Sooner than later, the U.S. might realize the value of Indian immigrants and their contribution. Jealousy could give way to appreciation. Hindus are unlike others, not a conquering people. We allow others to co-exist. Why Hindus give
importance to Education
Simply put Cooperate, Compete and Atmanirbharta should be our policy. National Interest should guide India at all times. The detailed areas of co-operation require a separate article.
Speaking long-term, an India U.S. combine can be mutually benefical and keep China on its toes. Standing alone, neither might be able to. The U.S. has Technology, Capital and India Talent. That makes a powerful combination.
India could help
the U.S. in its transition from being the only superpower to being one of the
many superpowers.
Americans must realize that what goes up also has to come down, the importance of SAMAH-time and Law
of Karma not to miss a deeper understanding of Asia.
Also read
1.
When USA starts
behaving like an emerging market
2.
San Jose Gurdwara,
California, USA
3.
Museum of Fine
Arts Boston
4.
Ashrams Los
Angeles and around
5.
Comparing state of
democracy USA vs India
6.
USA needs Indian
Pharma and India needs US market
7.
Cooperate, Compete, Atmanirbharta should be India’s mantra
8.
What does American
Exceptionalism mean
9.
Human Rights in
Sanatana Dharma
10.
How the Iran War Exposes Cracks in America’s Foundation
11.
How the Iran War
may change the world
12.
Explained China
USA Soyabean trade
13.
Why USA imports
Petroleum products from India
14.
USA – a Losing Superpower
To read all
articles on Foreign Policy
To see albums of
USA
Except last pic Shenzhen that is courtesy BBC News all pictures are by Author. This article should not be reproduced without written permission of www.esamskriti.com